When you’re injured in an accident, dealing with your damaged vehicle shouldn’t add to your stress. While most personal injury law firms in Texas tell clients to handle their own property damage claims, McKay Law PLLC takes a different approach—we handle every aspect of your property damage recovery at absolutely no charge to you.
This comprehensive service sets us apart from virtually every competitor in East Texas and beyond. Here’s exactly how we maximize your property damage settlement while you focus on healing.
Why Property Damage Matters More Than You Think
Your vehicle isn’t just property—it’s your livelihood, your family’s transportation, and often represents significant financial value. Yet most personal injury attorneys view property damage as a distraction from the “real” case: your bodily injury claim.
At McKay Law, we see it differently. Your property damage claim is an integral part of your recovery, and settling it quickly and favorably can provide immediate financial relief while your injury case progresses.
The McKay Law Property Damage Advantage
What We Handle (That Other Firms Don’t)
Most Texas personal injury law firms will tell you one of three things about property damage:
- “Handle it yourself with the insurance company”
- “We can refer you to a body shop”
- “We only handle injury claims, not property damage”
McKay Law handles it all—completely free of charge:
- Total loss negotiations
- Diminished value claims
- Repair estimate disputes
- Rental car reimbursement
- Personal property recovery
- Storage fee negotiations
- Salvage title prevention strategies
The McKay Law Property Damage Settlement Process
Step 1: Immediate Vehicle Documentation and Preservation
What We Do:
- Photograph all damage from multiple angles within 24-48 hours
- Document pre-accident vehicle condition using available records
- Secure the vehicle to prevent additional damage or storage fees
- Obtain official accident reports and witness statements
- Preserve evidence of third-party liability
Negotiation Points:
- Establishing clear liability through photographic evidence
- Demonstrating pre-accident vehicle value and condition
- Preventing insurance company arguments about “pre-existing damage”
Step 2: Independent Valuation Assessment
What We Do:
- Order professional appraisals from certified vehicle valuators
- Research comparable vehicle sales in your local market
- Document all vehicle options, upgrades, and special features
- Review maintenance records that increase vehicle value
- Calculate accurate fair market value, not insurance company estimates
Negotiation Points:
- Challenging lowball insurance valuations with market data
- Highlighting recent maintenance and upgrades that add value
- Using multiple valuation sources (NADA, Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds, actual local sales)
- Demonstrating regional market variations that favor higher values
Step 3: Total Loss vs. Repair Analysis
What We Do:
- Obtain multiple repair estimates from certified body shops
- Calculate actual cash value (ACV) vs. repair costs
- Analyze whether vehicle meets total loss threshold (typically 70-80% of ACV in Texas)
- Review title branding consequences
- Advise clients on financial implications of each option
Negotiation Points:
- Challenging premature total loss determinations
- Negotiating to keep repairs below total loss threshold when beneficial
- Arguing for total loss when repairs would leave diminished value
- Preventing salvage or rebuilt title designations that destroy resale value
Step 4: Diminished Value Claims (The Hidden Money)
What We Do:
- Calculate inherent diminished value using the 17c formula
- Obtain professional diminished value appraisals
- Research comparable vehicle sales showing accident-history price reductions
- Document how accident reporting (CARFAX, AutoCheck) reduces market value
- File formal diminished value claims with supporting documentation
Negotiation Points:
- Educating adjusters about Texas law recognizing diminished value
- Presenting 17c calculations: Base value × 10% cap × damage multiplier × mileage multiplier
- Demonstrating actual market impact through comparable sales data
- Overcoming insurance company resistance with professional appraisals
- Negotiating settlements typically ranging from $1,500 to $10,000+ depending on vehicle value
This is money most accident victims never know they’re entitled to—and most law firms never pursue.
Step 5: Rental Vehicle Reimbursement Maximization
What We Do:
- Immediately arrange rental vehicles through client’s insurance or at-fault party’s coverage
- Track all rental days and ensure proper billing
- Negotiate extended rental periods during repair delays
- Fight rental cutoffs before repairs are complete
- Recover rental costs even when client uses alternative transportation
Negotiation Points:
- Establishing reasonable rental duration based on repair complexity
- Challenging arbitrary rental cutoff dates
- Arguing for comparable vehicle class rental rates
- Recovering loss of use damages when rental isn’t obtained
- Negotiating lump-sum loss of use payments
Step 6: Personal Property Recovery
What We Do:
- Inventory all personal property damaged or lost in the accident
- Document values with receipts, photos, or replacement cost research
- Include items often overlooked: child car seats, electronics, clothing, tools, eyeglasses
- Prepare itemized personal property claims
- Negotiate separate property damage settlements
Negotiation Points:
- Establishing replacement cost vs. actual cash value
- Overcoming insurance company skepticism about claimed items
- Negotiating reasonable settlements even without receipts
- Including safety items that must be replaced (car seats after any accident)
Step 7: Storage and Towing Fee Negotiations
What We Do:
- Immediately contact tow companies to minimize accumulating storage fees
- Negotiate storage fee waivers or reductions
- Arrange vehicle transfers to preferred locations
- Ensure insurance companies pay reasonable towing and storage
- Prevent liens on vehicles from unpaid storage
Negotiation Points:
- Arguing insurance company responsibility for unreasonable delays causing storage fees
- Negotiating direct payment to storage facilities
- Reducing or eliminating excessive per-day storage charges
- Preventing client out-of-pocket expenses for storage
Step 8: Strategic Timing and Leverage
What We Do:
- Determine optimal timing for property damage settlement
- Coordinate property settlements with injury claim strategy
- Maintain leverage through documentation and preparation
- Decide when to settle property damage independently vs. as package deal
- Use property damage as negotiation leverage for injury claims
Negotiation Points:
- Settling property damage quickly for immediate client relief
- Reserving injury claims for maximum settlement leverage
- Using strong property damage case as proof of liability
- Demonstrating professional case management to insurance adjusters
- Building credibility for larger injury claim negotiations
Step 9: Final Settlement Negotiation and Documentation
What We Do:
- Present comprehensive demand packages with all supporting documentation
- Negotiate maximum settlements through multiple rounds if necessary
- Review all settlement agreements before client signature
- Ensure settlements include all damage categories
- Obtain settlement checks and facilitate prompt client payment
- Resolve all liens and payoffs
Negotiation Points:
- Countering initial lowball offers with documented evidence
- Using comparable settlements as negotiation benchmarks
- Leveraging litigation threat when negotiations stall
- Ensuring settlement releases properly protect client’s injury claim
- Confirming no outstanding obligations remain after settlement
Step 10: Post-Settlement Vehicle Transactions
What We Do:
- Facilitate vehicle sales to salvage buyers when totaled
- Negotiate salvage retention when clients want to keep vehicles
- Handle title transfers and DMV paperwork
- Ensure proper lien releases from finance companies
- Coordinate gap insurance claims when applicable
- Assist with replacement vehicle purchases using settlement funds
Negotiation Points:
- Maximizing salvage offers through competitive bidding
- Reducing salvage value deductions from total loss settlements
- Negotiating gap insurance coverage for settlement shortfalls
Real Results: Property Damage Settlements That Made a Difference
Example 1: The Undervalued Pickup Truck
- Insurance offer: $12,500
- McKay Law settlement: $18,750 + $3,200 diminished value
- Additional recovery: $6,450
- Time to settlement: 18 days
Example 2: The Premature Total Loss
- Insurance total loss offer: $8,900
- McKay Law negotiated repairs: $6,200 (avoided salvage title)
- Diminished value recovery: $2,100
- Client kept vehicle without title damage
Example 3: The Forgotten Personal Property
- Insurance property damage: $15,200 vehicle settlement
- McKay Law added: $2,850 personal property (laptop, tools, child car seats, clothing)
- Items insurance “didn’t cover”: We recovered them all
Why This Matters: The Financial Impact
Consider a typical McKay Law client after a serious truck accident:
Without McKay Law’s Property Damage Services:
- Accepts insurance company’s vehicle valuation: $16,000
- Handles own property claim, misses diminished value: $0
- Pays rental car expenses out-of-pocket: -$450
- Loses personal property value: -$800
- Net property recovery: $14,750
With McKay Law’s Complete Property Damage Service:
- Negotiated vehicle settlement: $19,200
- Diminished value recovery: $3,400
- Rental reimbursement: $1,200
- Personal property recovery: $1,350
- Total property recovery: $25,150
McKay Law difference: $10,400 additional recovery—at zero cost to the client.
That’s real money in your pocket while your injury case proceeds. For many families, it’s the difference between financial crisis and stability after an accident.
The Competitive Advantage You Deserve
When you hire most personal injury law firms in Dallas, Tyler, Sulphur Springs, or anywhere in East Texas, you’re getting injury representation only. You’re on your own for property damage, navigating insurance adjusters who know you’re unrepresented and vulnerable.
When you hire McKay Law, you get complete accident recovery representation:
✓ Full property damage negotiation at no charge ✓ Maximum vehicle settlement recovery ✓ Diminished value claims other firms ignore ✓ Personal property recovery ✓ Rental reimbursement ✓ Expert negotiation on every damage category ✓ Immediate financial relief while injury case proceeds ✓ One firm, complete recovery, zero additional fees
Our Property Damage Guarantee
We handle your property damage claim with the same aggressive, professional representation we bring to your injury case:
- No attorney fees for property damage work – completely free service
- No recovery, no cost – if we don’t increase your settlement, you pay nothing
- Fast results – most property claims settled within 2-4 weeks
- Maximum recovery – we fight for every dollar you’re owed
- Complete transparency – you understand every step and decision
Who Benefits Most from McKay Law’s Property Damage Services?
Truck Accident Victims Commercial truck accidents often cause severe vehicle damage and total losses. Insurance companies know these cases involve large injury claims and may undervalue property damage hoping you’ll accept less overall. We maximize both.
Multiple Vehicle Accidents Complex accidents with multiple at-fault parties require strategic property damage negotiations across several insurance companies. We handle the complexity.
High-Value Vehicle Owners Luxury vehicles, trucks with extensive upgrades, or newer vehicles with high fair market values require expert negotiation and professional appraisals. We ensure you receive full value.
Commercial Vehicle Owners Business vehicle losses impact your livelihood. We understand commercial vehicle valuations and lost income implications.
Clients with Financed Vehicles When you owe more than the insurance settlement, we negotiate gap coverage and maximum settlements to minimize your out-of-pocket loss.
Why Other Firms Don’t Offer This Service
The honest answer? Property damage claims require time, expertise, and resources that most personal injury firms don’t want to invest for “small” settlements that don’t generate attorney fees.
At McKay Law, we see it differently:
- Complete client service – We represent the whole person, not just their injury claim
- Immediate client relief – Property settlements provide fast financial help when clients need it most
- Stronger cases – Professionally handled property damage establishes our credibility and strengthens injury negotiations
- Better outcomes – Clients who aren’t financially desperate make better injury settlement decisions
- It’s the right thing to do – We’re invested in your complete recovery, not just our fee
Property Damage FAQs
Q: Do I pay attorney fees on my property damage settlement? A: No. McKay Law handles all property damage negotiations at absolutely no cost to you. Our contingency fee applies only to your injury recovery.
Q: How long does property damage settlement take? A: Most property damage claims settle within 2-4 weeks. Total loss cases often settle within days. We work quickly to provide immediate financial relief.
Q: What if the insurance company already made me an offer? A: Let us review it before you accept. Insurance companies routinely lowball unrepresented accident victims. We can likely negotiate a significantly higher settlement.
Q: Can I keep my car if it’s totaled? A: Yes, through salvage retention. We’ll negotiate the salvage value deduction and help you decide if keeping the vehicle makes financial sense.
Q: What is diminished value and do I qualify? A: Diminished value is the reduction in your vehicle’s market value due to accident history, even after perfect repairs. In Texas, if you’re not at fault and your vehicle is repaired (not totaled), you likely qualify for diminished value compensation.
Q: Will settling property damage hurt my injury claim? A: No. Property damage and bodily injury are separate claims. We strategically settle property damage quickly while preserving all leverage for your injury claim.
Q: What if I already settled my property damage? A: Contact us anyway. We can still handle your injury claim, and we may identify additional property damage recovery opportunities like diminished value claims.
Take the First Step Toward Complete Recovery
Your accident caused property damage AND personal injuries. You deserve a law firm that fights for complete recovery in both areas.
Most East Texas personal injury law firms will tell you to “work it out with the insurance company” on your property damage. McKay Law tells you: “We’ll handle everything.”
Contact McKay Law Today
Sulphur Springs Office [Office Address] Dallas Office [Office Address] Tyler Office [Office Address]
Call 24/7: [Phone Number] Online: McKayLawTx.com
Free Consultation • No Attorney Fees for Property Damage Services • Maximum Recovery Guarantee
Why McKay Law? 340+ Five-Star Reviews Say It All
“McKay Law not only got me a great settlement for my injuries, but they fought the insurance company to get me $4,000 more for my truck than they originally offered. I didn’t even know I could get diminished value money until they explained it. Most lawyers wouldn’t have bothered with my truck claim.” — James R., Sulphur Springs
“After my accident, I was overwhelmed trying to deal with the body shop, rental car company, and insurance adjuster while recovering from my injuries. McKay Law took over everything related to my car and got it all settled in two weeks. I could focus on healing while they handled the stress.” — Maria G., Tyler
“Other law firms told me to handle my property damage myself. McKay Law saw it as part of my case and recovered $8,000 more than the insurance company’s first offer—all without charging me any attorney fees for that work. That’s the difference.” — Robert T., Dallas
Over 60 Years of Combined Legal Experience • Serving East Texas With Offices in Sulphur Springs, Dallas, and Tyler
When your accident involves property damage and personal injuries, you need a law firm that handles both expertly and completely. McKay Law delivers maximum recovery for your vehicle, your belongings, and your injuries—all at no additional cost to you.
Get the complete representation you deserve. Contact McKay Law today.
This comprehensive approach to property damage claims is just one example of how McKay Law goes above and beyond for our clients. Whether you’ve been injured in a truck accident, suffered a workplace injury, or lost a loved one in a wrongful death case, we bring the same thorough, aggressive representation to every aspect of your recovery.
Retry
